{"name":"4 Seasons Pay on Proof network rules","url":"https://www.build4seasons.com/pay-on-proof/network/rules.json","pageUrl":"https://www.build4seasons.com/pay-on-proof/network/rules","schema":1,"version":"0df5d61188ac","status":{"draft":true,"counsel":"not_reviewed","note":"Draft for counsel. Counsel has not reviewed these rules, and nothing here is legal advice."},"builtOn":{"disputeRules":{"version":"2e90440bb009","path":"/pay-on-proof/rules","jsonPath":"/pay-on-proof/rules.json"},"proofStandard":{"release":1,"effective":"2026-11-13","path":"/pay-on-proof/standard","jsonPath":"/pay-on-proof/standard.json"}},"values":{"planReviewDays":3,"jobReviewHours":24,"planRespondDays":3,"planDecideBusinessDays":5,"certifyMinLiveReleases":20,"certifyMaxHeldOnReviewBps":1000,"certifyConformanceMaxAgeDays":90,"reserveEnabled":false,"reserveShareBps":0,"reserveHoldDays":0,"clauseInPlan":false,"programApi":false},"sections":[{"id":"proof","title":"What counts as proof","lede":"Proof is judged against the published proof standard, the same one the 4 Seasons API runs.","rules":[{"id":"proof-standard","kind":"system","who":"system","title":"The proof standard","text":"Each step kind's proof is set out in the proof standard, release 1, at /pay-on-proof/standard. A release decision names the standard release it was made under.","basis":"proof-standard.ts proofStandard, release-decision"},{"id":"proof-sealed","kind":"system","who":"member","title":"Sealed photos","text":"A sealed photo counts when it passes the signature, device, nonce, hash, time, reference checks.","basis":"sealed-capture.ts CAPTURE_CHECKS, assessCapture"},{"id":"proof-machine","kind":"system","who":"member","title":"Machine records","text":"A machine record is labelled machine proof and must pass the signature, device, reference, window, expectation checks. It is evidence. A person decides on it.","basis":"machine-proof.ts TELEMETRY_CHECKS, assessTelemetry"}]},{"id":"release","title":"When money is released","lede":"Release follows the windows in the dispute rulebook, as configured today.","rules":[{"id":"release-plan","kind":"system","who":"payer","title":"On a plan","text":"After proof arrives the payer has 3 days to release the milestone or raise an issue. If they do neither, it releases to the member on its own. A signed plan keeps the review days it was signed with.","basis":"dispute rule window-plan-review"},{"id":"release-job","kind":"system","who":"payer","title":"On a 4 Seasons job","text":"A passed step's payment waits 24 hours before the saved method is charged, unless the payer releases or holds it sooner.","basis":"dispute rule window-job-review"},{"id":"release-held","kind":"system","who":"system","title":"While an issue is open","text":"Money for a milestone with an open issue stays where it is. Nothing is transferred and nothing is refunded until the issue ends.","basis":"dispute rule pay-plan"}]},{"id":"disputes","title":"Disputes and decisions","lede":"Disputes follow the dispute rulebook, version 2e90440bb009, at /pay-on-proof/rules.","rules":[{"id":"disputes-answer","kind":"system","who":"member","title":"Answering an issue","text":"The member answers an issue within 3 days. One nobody has answered by then goes to 4 Seasons on its own.","basis":"dispute rule window-plan-respond"},{"id":"disputes-decide","kind":"signed_plan","who":"4seasons","title":"A decision by 4 Seasons","text":"A person at 4 Seasons decides from the record within 5 business days of being asked, and writes the reason. The outcome is one of release, partial release, rework, then release, refund.","basis":"dispute rule window-plan-decide, stage-decide"},{"id":"disputes-limits","kind":"system","who":"4seasons","title":"What a decision covers","text":"A decision covers where one held payment goes. It is not arbitration and it does not decide the construction contract between the two sides.","basis":"dispute rule scope-limits"}]},{"id":"members","title":"What a member does","lede":"A member is a contractor, company or machine operator paid through the network, and the software they send proof from.","rules":[{"id":"member-proof","kind":"system","who":"member","title":"Send proof to the standard","text":"Send proof for each milestone as the proof standard sets out for its step kind. Proof that fails a check is shown with the failed check, and the payer sees it.","basis":"settlement.ts checkStepProof, protected.ts proofFlags"},{"id":"member-keys","kind":"draft","who":"member","title":"Keep capture keys to yourself","text":"Register each capture device's key, keep its private key on the device, and tell 4 Seasons the same day a device is lost so its key can be revoked.","basis":"proposed"},{"id":"member-fix","kind":"draft","who":"member","title":"Fix what is upheld","text":"When a claim on your verified work is upheld, fix it within the days the guarantee sets, or the cost is recovered as the guarantee terms say.","basis":"proposed"},{"id":"member-certified","kind":"system","who":"member","title":"Certified on the network","text":"A member shows Certified on the network while four things hold. Their latest conformance run, which 4 Seasons runs on their own captures and records, passed within the last 90 days. They have at least 20 live verified releases on record. At most 10% of their reviewed decisions ended in a hold. And 4 Seasons has left it in place. Anyone can check it at /api/v1/network/certifications.","basis":"network-rules.ts certificationFor, platform network-certification.ts"}]},{"id":"payers","title":"What a payer does","lede":"A payer is whoever pays for the outcome, such as a homeowner, a company or a program.","rules":[{"id":"payer-fund","kind":"signed_plan","who":"payer","title":"Pay in before the work","text":"Each milestone's money is paid in shortly before that milestone starts. The payment provider holds it until it is released.","basis":"protected.ts planText, fundMilestone"},{"id":"payer-review","kind":"system","who":"payer","title":"Review proof in time","text":"Release the milestone or raise an issue within 3 days of proof arriving.","basis":"dispute rule window-plan-review"},{"id":"payer-issue","kind":"system","who":"payer","title":"Say what is wrong","text":"Raise an issue with a reason from the list and a note of at least 10 characters.","basis":"dispute rule reasons-plan"}]},{"id":"suspension","title":"Suspension","lede":"What happens when a member stops meeting the rules.","rules":[{"id":"suspend-certification","kind":"system","who":"4seasons","title":"Certification ends on its own","text":"Certification ends as soon as one of its checks fails, such as an old conformance run. It comes back when the checks pass again.","basis":"network-rules.ts certificationFor"},{"id":"suspend-revoke","kind":"system","who":"4seasons","title":"Revoked by a person","text":"A person at 4 Seasons can revoke a member's certification with a written reason. The reason is kept on the record and shown to anyone who checks.","basis":"platform network-certification.ts revokeNetworkCertification"},{"id":"suspend-access","kind":"draft","who":"4seasons","title":"Suspension from the network","text":"A member who sends proof that was altered, or who leaves an upheld claim unfixed and unpaid, can be suspended from new plans. Money already paid in for their signed plans keeps the rules it was signed under.","basis":"proposed"}]},{"id":"us","title":"In the United States","lede":"These rules depend on where the work is. Today they cover work in the United States only.","rules":[{"id":"us-provider","kind":"system","who":"system","title":"Who holds the money","text":"Plan money is paid through Stripe and held by Stripe until it is released to the member or refunded to the payer.","basis":"protected.ts fundMilestone, settleMilestone"},{"id":"us-bank","kind":"draft","who":"payer","title":"Raise an issue here first","text":"Raise an issue on the network before opening a card dispute with the bank. A card dispute stays open to the payer either way, and the bank decides it.","basis":"proposed"},{"id":"us-waiver","kind":"system","who":"system","title":"Lien waivers","text":"A lien waiver for a milestone is generated only when money for it is released to the member, and it is for the amount released.","basis":"dispute rule waiver-plan"}]},{"id":"reserve","title":"The network guarantee reserve","lede":"The reserve is switched off. No money is held for it.","rules":[{"id":"reserve-hold","kind":"system","who":"system","title":"What is held","text":"While the reserve is off, nothing is held from any release and the reserve ledger stays empty.","basis":"network-rules.ts reserveHoldCents, network.reserve.*"},{"id":"reserve-claims","kind":"system","who":"system","title":"Used first for upheld claims","text":"An upheld claim on a member's work is paid from that member's held amounts first, oldest first, before anything else.","basis":"network-rules.ts reserveForClaim"}]}],"clause":{"version":"0df5d61188ac","en":"Network rules. Payments under this plan follow the 4 Seasons Pay on Proof network rules, version 0df5d61188ac, published at https://www.build4seasons.com/pay-on-proof/network/rules. Where this plan and those rules differ, this plan applies.","es":"Reglas de la red. Los pagos de este plan siguen las reglas de la red Pay on Proof de 4 Seasons, versión 0df5d61188ac, publicadas en https://www.build4seasons.com/pay-on-proof/network/rules. Donde este plan y esas reglas no coincidan, se aplica este plan.","note":"Draft for counsel. Counsel has not reviewed these rules, and nothing here is legal advice. Do not put this clause in a contract until counsel has reviewed it."},"programVerification":{"schema":"4s.program_verification.v0","enabled":false}}